Republicans need history lesson about their party if they want to move on from defeat

Nov 16, 2026 - 08:30
 0  1
Republicans need history lesson about their party if they want to move on from defeat

The Republican Party is at a critically important crossroads.

Understanding those crossroads and how to navigate back to a majority is a major, immediate challenge.

Historically, it took Republicans a long time to recover from the Great Depression. We had become a minority party with limited appeal to over half of the country.

REPUBLICANS HAVE A MIDTERM PROBLEM. REAGAN’S AMERICAN VISION IS THE ANSWER

In 1980, President Ronald Reagan gave us the potential to be a truly national party for the first time since President Franklin Delano Roosevelt used the pain of the Great Depression to build massive support for the enlarged government of the New Deal and the Democratic Party that created it.

In 1994, after 16 years of endless work (outlined in "March to the Majority" with Joe Gaylord, who was my partner for all those years), the Contract with America broke the Democrats’ 40-year monopoly on the U.S. House. Two years later, in 1996, the House GOP was re-elected as a majority for the first time since 1928. A genuine two-party Congress was established for the first time in two generations.

NEWT GINGRICH: REPUBLICANS CAN WIN THE 2026 MIDTERMS — IF THEY FOLLOW THE PLAN

Then in 2015 and 2016, then-citizen Donald Trump appealed to a wide range of hardworking people who were fed up with the corruption, left-wing extremism and dictatorial Washington bureaucracy that made their lives unhappy. By 2024, the bond between President Trump and his supporters — and their hostility to the efforts of the left to destroy him physically and legally — led the Republican Party to the edge of a genuine majority coalition for the first time since 1928.

Then, at the beginning of 2025, just as we seemed on the verge of becoming a new governing majority coalition, Republicans forgot the key rules President Abraham Lincoln taught us during the GOP’s foundational period in the 1850s and 1860s.

HUGH HEWITT: THE GOP IS WOUNDED, NOT DEAD — BUT RECOVERY HAS TO START NOW

Lincoln warned that "with public sentiment, nothing can fail; without it nothing can succeed." He instructed us in the Gettysburg Address that we were for "government of the people, by the people, for the people."

Suddenly in 2026, Republicans who had been doing a pretty good job of paying attention to the American people decided they knew more than the voters who elected them.

JUSTIN HASKINS: 3 HUGE REASONS REPUBLICANS LOST. HERE’S WHAT THEY NEED TO WIN IN 2028

Republicans also reverted to a belief that enough money could drown the common sense of the American people — and that clever consultants could focus the debate and highlight selected facts, so voters would do what the consultants wanted.

In some ways, the 2026 election was one of the great vindications of the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. Voters took back control of their country, rejected the tidal wave of advertising and political spending, and sent back a tidal wave of votes.

CONSERVATIVES STUNNED BY 'CATASTROPHIC' MIDTERM BLUE TSUNAMI, BLAME TRUMP'S IRAN WAR, HIGH GAS PRICES

Everyday folks got angry filling up their gas tanks, buying heating oil for the winter and trying to afford groceries. Then they watched a parade of billionaires who seemed to be crowding out everyday Americans who had built this country and made it an exceptional center of freedom. So, they decided to vote their anger.

In places such as Texas, where the Republican Senate nominee may have been the most indefensible candidate in the country, people said, "Not you." They didn’t care what GOP ads said. In a shocking summary judgment, Texans not only gave Democrat James Talarico 55% of the vote, but they also wiped out every statewide Republican executive official. This was a result no one outside of Texas (and especially Washington) could have predicted.

DEMOCRAT GINA HINOJOSA STUNS ABBOTT, MAKES HISTORY AS FIRST LATINA TEXAS GOVERNOR

In Ohio, Vivek Ramaswamy ran a commercial in which his opponent’s mother attacked her. It may have been the single most self-destructive ad run anywhere in the country. It was an insult to the intelligence and decency of every Ohioan.

In Mississippi, the Republican incumbent senator had said that the answer to the high price of beef was the lower cost of many other types of protein. Somehow, suggesting that Mississippians eat tofu didn’t seem to appeal to most of her voters. In some ways, it was a "let them eat cake" moment. She went from being safe in January to losing by about 6,000 votes.

TREY GOWDY: THE MIDTERMS WERE A PAINFUL LESSON THAT REPUBLICANS CAN'T SKIP LEARNING

So, Republicans need to simply make a choice. Are they going to follow the politics of Lincoln, which begins with the wishes of the American people — or the politics of money, special interests and ideologies that ignore the popular sentiment?

There is a great opportunity for Republicans to see the 2026 results as a wake-up call to ask the American people what problems they want solved and what values they want defended — and then to go solve those problems and defend those values.

VANCE, CRUZ AND DESANTIS DIAGNOSE GOP'S MIDTERM DISASTER AS BATTLE OVER PARTY'S FUTURE BEGINS

A Republican Party that’s focused on the American people will rebound with startling speed as the Democrats fail to solve practical problems and seek to impose radical values.

To this end, Jim Jordan must see himself as the imminent speaker of the House and not as the incoming House minority leader. He must insist on spending two-thirds of his time on positive solutions the American people want and only one-third on what the Democrats are doing wrong.

Similarly, the 2028 Republican presidential campaign should focus on what we will do better and what we will solve, not on what the Democrats are doing wrong.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

There is a deep hunger for a Lincoln-based GOP that listens to and works with the American people.

That’s where the GOP should always be — and where it should go from here.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM NEWT GINGRICH

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0